Loyalty programs promise businesses better customer retention and profits, but they often fail due to high costs, low engagement, and operational challenges. Here’s a quick breakdown of why they don’t work and better alternatives:

• High Costs: Businesses spend millions on setup, salaries, and maintenance, often outweighing the benefits.

• Low Engagement: 78% of customers abandon programs if rewards are slow or unappealing, with $16 billion in rewards going unredeemed annually.

• Data Security Issues: 86% of people worry about their data, and breaches are costly to prevent.

• Generic Rewards: Lack of variety and relevance in rewards pushes customers away.

Better Alternatives:

1. Personalized Shopping Experiences: Tailor offers based on customer behavior to boost engagement.

2. Subscription Models: Provide steady revenue and stronger customer ties.

3. Data-Driven Insights: Use analytics to predict and meet customer needs.

Loyalty programs often fail to deliver real value. Businesses should focus on personalized, data-driven strategies to build lasting connections and improve profitability.

Why Most Loyalty Programs Fail (And How to Fix It)

Why Most Loyalty Programs Fail

Loyalty programs are everywhere, but many fail to deliver the profits businesses expect. Instead, they often become costly ventures that struggle to keep up with market demands.

High Costs Outweigh the Benefits

Launching or updating a loyalty program isn't cheap - businesses spend an average of $375,000 just to get started. Add to that the cost of staffing, with a typical team of 16 employees earning an average of $117,749 each. That’s nearly $1.9 million in annual salaries alone. While loyalty program members can generate 16–18% more revenue, these gains are often eaten up by expenses like technology, training, customer support, marketing, system integration, and ongoing maintenance. On top of that, companies face growing pressure to protect customer data, which adds another layer of cost and complexity.

The Challenge of Customer Data Security

Data security is a major concern for consumers. In fact, 86% of people worry about how their data is handled, and nearly half (48%) have walked away from purchases due to privacy concerns.

"Securing customers' data is just one way to demonstrate that you take their safety seriously and create a bond of trust." – COMARCH SA

The risks are real - 88% of security breaches are caused by human error. To safeguard customer trust, companies need to invest in advanced security measures, train employees thoroughly, conduct regular audits, and ensure compliance with data protection regulations.

Discounts That Damage Profits

Offering discounts might seem like a great way to attract customers, but it can backfire. A mere 5% discount can cut profitability in half. This often leads businesses into a dangerous cycle of offering deeper discounts, which trains customers to expect lower prices instead of paying full value.

Take Target, for example. In 2023, the company moved away from blanket discounts and focused on personalized promotions. The result? Conversion rates tripled. This shift highlights the need for businesses to rethink their approach to customer loyalty, moving beyond simple price cuts to strategies that encourage long-term engagement.

Poor Customer Engagement Results

After looking at the high costs and risks tied to traditional loyalty programs, it's clear they also fail to genuinely connect with customers. While these programs aim to strengthen customer relationships, they often fall short, leaving a gap between sign-ups and true engagement. The numbers speak for themselves.

Most Points Go Unused

Every year in the U.S., a staggering $16 billion in loyalty rewards goes unredeemed. Americans rack up about $48 billion in rewards points and air travel miles annually, yet the average household actively engages with fewer than half of the 18.4 programs they’re enrolled in.

Why are so many rewards left on the table? Here’s what the data shows:

• 57% of consumers say it takes too long to earn meaningful rewards.

• 57% don’t know their current point balance.

• 38% don’t understand the value of their points.

• 53% find the rewards unappealing.

"If redemption equals engagement and engagement delivers customer satisfaction and profits, then loyalty marketers should encourage their members to make the most of their rewards. In short, redemption is good." – Kelly Hlavinka, Managing Partner at COLLOQUY

The problem doesn’t stop at unredeemed rewards. Many programs fail to stand out, offering rewards that feel generic and uninspired.

Similar Rewards Across Brands

A major issue with loyalty programs is the lack of variety in their rewards. When rewards feel the same across different brands, customers lose interest. In fact, 33% of consumers are likely to leave even their favorite brands if the rewards don’t feel relevant.

Take Bergzeit, a German retailer specializing in mountaineering products. They revamped their loyalty program by adding a sports tracker that rewarded customers with bonus points for climbing achievements. The result? A 95% increase in the average frequency of orders per member.

"According to our research, forward-thinking brands must obsess over ensuring their loyalty program members derive equal, if not more, value than they invest. To optimize this value exchange, brands must understand their members on a deeper, more personal level to make them feel appreciated and cherished. This means providing ease of use, helpful recommendations, and most importantly, reward options that resonate and drive feelings of gratification. With satisfaction comes engagement - and an increase in the rate at which consumers earn and spend their rewards. This ongoing 'earn and burn' cycle directly correlates with more frequent touchpoints that can drive increased revenue potential and loyalty program success for businesses." – James Berry, Managing Director at Valuedynamx

The numbers back this up. With an average redemption rate of just 13.67%, traditional programs leave billions in unused rewards and countless missed opportunities to build stronger customer relationships. Instead of fostering loyalty, these programs often create frustration, falling far short of their potential.

Better Ways to Keep Customers

Creative retention strategies can outperform outdated methods. Here are some approaches that help businesses build real connections and encourage long-term growth.

Custom Shopping Experiences

Tailoring the shopping experience can strengthen customer relationships. For example, Industry West, a furniture retailer, adjusted its online content to match different customer segments. The result? A 15% boost in average order value, with 25% of sales linked to these personalized experiences.

Here’s how they did it:

• New visitors were shown trending products.

• Repeat visitors received recommendations based on their browsing history.

• Past buyers were targeted with personalized offers.

• Product pages highlighted relevant bestsellers.

"We wanted to bring the in-store shopping experience online. Searchspring helped us achieve this with personalized product offerings, giving us more control over our online product merchandising and improving our on-site marketing capabilities." - John Jordan, Director of Ecommerce, Mast General Store

Smart Customer Analysis

Data analysis goes beyond simple personalization, offering ways to refine customer interactions. Mast General Store discovered that search users were 4.3 times more likely to make a purchase and 5.4 times more valuable.

Some benefits of smart analysis include:

• Tracking behavior across multiple touchpoints.

• Identifying high-value customer groups.

• Predicting when customers are likely to buy.

• Offering recommendations tailored to browsing habits.

Using these insights, businesses can create subscription models that provide steady income while strengthening customer relationships.

Subscription-Based Loyalty

Subscription programs, designed to meet customer needs, are a step above generic point-based rewards. In fact, subscription businesses have grown by over 350% in recent years, with subscribers being 43% more likely to make weekly purchases.

Take Smol, a 2018 startup offering eco-friendly cleaning products. Their success is built on:

• Flexible product options.

• Adjustable delivery schedules.

• Easy pause or cancellation features.

• Tools to track environmental impact.

Subscriptions deliver convenience and real benefits. Plus, 80% of consumers are more likely to buy when brands offer tailored experiences.

Key elements of a strong subscription model include:

• A clear value proposition.

• Flexible product and delivery options.

• Exclusive perks for subscribers.

• Transparent pricing.

• A sense of community built around shared values.

The goal is to treat subscribers like partners, focusing on flexibility and consistent value.

Key Metrics for Customer Loyalty

After examining the limitations of traditional loyalty programs and exploring better strategies, it’s crucial to measure loyalty effectively. Certain metrics provide a clear picture of genuine customer loyalty.

Customer Lifetime Value (CLV)

Customer Lifetime Value (CLV) measures the total revenue a customer is expected to generate over their relationship with your business. This long-term metric outweighs short-term loyalty program gains.

To calculate CLV, focus on these key areas:

For example, REN Skincare saw a 68% increase in customer spending and 63% higher repeat purchases by revamping their loyalty approach. Their success highlights the importance of personalized strategies that encourage long-term growth.

Purchase Frequency Tracking

Tracking how often customers make purchases provides more insight into loyalty than simply monitoring points. The Vitamin Shoppe discovered this when they adjusted their program to focus on spending thresholds at higher tiers.

Key indicators to monitor include:

• Repeat purchase rate: Reflects loyalty levels.

• Average time between orders: Reveals buying habits.

• Product category preferences: Helps predict future purchases.

• Seasonal trends: Assists in inventory planning.

This data helps refine loyalty programs and align them with customer behavior.

"Contrary to popular belief, making customers feel content, happy, or delighted impacts loyalty less than making customers feel respected, understood, valued, or confident." - Joana de Quintanilha, VP and principal analyst at Forrester

Retention vs. Acquisition Costs

It’s widely accepted that retaining customers costs far less than acquiring new ones - five times less, to be exact. Waterdrop’s experience supports this: they boosted customer spending by 90% by prioritizing retention through their loyalty program, which also helped lower acquisition costs.

Some key stats to consider:

• Existing customers spend 31% more per order compared to new customers.

• A 5% increase in retention can lead to a 25-95% profit boost.

• 80% of future revenue often comes from 20% of current customers.

Conclusion

Traditional loyalty programs often fall short, weighed down by high costs and lackluster engagement. Instead of fostering strong customer connections, they can create more problems than benefits, such as excessive expenses and diminishing returns.

To stay ahead, businesses need to move beyond transactional rewards and focus on building real relationships with their customers. Here’s a quick recap of the strategies discussed earlier:

Real-world examples highlight the power of these approaches. For instance, Coca-Cola improved customer satisfaction by 21 points, while Hulu boosted revenue by 21% and reduced churn by 10% - all by embracing personalization.

Now is the time to rethink your loyalty strategy. By focusing on tailored experiences, leveraging data insights, and offering flexible subscription options, you can break free from the limitations of outdated programs and meet the needs of today's consumers.

Related posts

• 7 Customer Retention Metrics Every eCommerce Brand Must Track

• Operational Debt Kills

• Inventory Is the New CAC

• Competitor Benchmarking Framework for FMCG Brands